SHARING THE LOAD:
Effluent Trading for Indirect Dischargers
Lessons from the New Jersey Chemical Industry Project--
Effluent Trading Team
Final Report May, 1998
Preface
The Environmental Protection Agency's Industry Strategies Division is working with the
New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection , US EPA Region 2, and a Stakeholder group made up
of industry, environmental group, union, and community representatives on a project with the
batch chemical manufacturing industry in New Jersey. The New Jersey Chemical Industry Project is
an effort to assess current environmental protection strategies on a sector basis and develop
better approaches.
The project started by asking what inspires companies to achieve - or keeps them from
achieving - better environmental performance. From this information, the Stakeholder group
developed a list of 45 issues for possible pilot projects to test new environmental protection
strategies. The Effluent Trading Pilot was developed as one of four pilot projects selected by
the New Jersey Chemical Industry Project Stakeholder group. The other pilots selected by the
group include: reuse of "waste" materials across facilities, compliance assistance, and flexible
track for good environmental performers.
A subset of the Stakeholder group formed the Pilot Team for the Effluent Trading Pilot, along
with several additional experts who were invited to participate. The Pilot Team worked together
to facilitate trading of local effluent pretreatment limits within the Passaic Valley Sewerage
Commissioners' treatment area. This report documents the lessons learned from establishing a
trade of pretreatment limits, as well as providing information on the structure and background of
the trade. It is hoped that this information will be helpful to others seeking to establish
effluent trades, especially among industrial dischargers.
In addition to this report, the New Jersey Chemical Industry
Project has prepared
reports on the work of the Materials Recycling Pilot Team, the Compliance Assistance Pilot
Team, and the Flexible Track Pilot Team. The Materials Recycling report, titled
Promoting Chemical Recycling: Resource
Conservation in Chemical Manufacturing, EPA 231-R-99-001, May 1999, describes five typical
batch chemical process scenarios that present opportunities to recycle materials, explains
how the hazardous waste regulations would apply to each scenario, and documents the
environmental and economic benefits that have been realized to date by the one scenario
that has already been implemented. The scenarios and regulatory interpretations may be
helpful to other facilities with similar processes that wish to improve their materials
reuse and recycling, including facilities outside of New Jersey. Because the New Jersey
hazardous waste rules are the same as the federal rules, the information in this report
may be useful to facilities in other states where the Federal rules apply.
The Compliance Assistance report describes how the Pilot Team developed compliance
assistance materials for New Jersey companies as an Industry-Government Team. The materials
include plain language descriptions of many NJ state environmental regulations and NJ DEP
compliance assistance activities, applicability flowcharts for six key regulations, and an extensive
bibliography of compliance assistance resources. The cooperative approach allowed the Pilot
Team to develop materials that were targeted to industry needs, used less agency resources, and
improved relationships between industry and regulators. The report is titled
Inspiring Performance: The Government-Industry Team Approach
to Improving Environmental Compliance (EPA-231-R-99-002, May 1999). The compliance
assistance materials that were developed can be viewed on the Internet at
http://www.state.nj.us/dep/
enforcement/home.htm. 
The Pilot Team for the final pilot, Flexible Track, has published a "Proposed Framework For a Flexible Track Program" which has served as the foundation for NJ DEP's Silver and Gold Track Programs . These programs provide incentives to facilites that are good environmental performers to maintain and improve their performance. The first element of the Silver Track Program was implemented in September 1999. The NJ DEP is continuing to work with a group of stakeholders from industry and environmental groups in developing the Silver Track II and Gold Track Programs.
For more information about the New Jersey Chemical Industry Project and the Effluent Trading
Pilot, contact:
- Catherine S. Tunis
- EPA Office of Policy, Economics and Innovation
- Ariel Rios Building
- 1200 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW (2129)
- Washington, D.C. 20460
- telephone: (202)-260-2698
- tunis.catherine@epamail.epa.gov
Download a PDF copy of this report (Adobe Acrobat 2.1 format)
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
PILOT TEAM MEMBERS
|